New to the vintage treasure hunt? Buying antique jewellery can feel daunting, but it doesn’t have to be.
Buying antique jewellery is as much about intuition as information. You’re not just choosing something beautiful, you’re choosing something that has lived. A piece that has been loved, worn, repaired, and passed down. It’s that history — the small marks of time, the sense of soul — that makes vintage jewellery unlike anything new.
If you’re new to collecting, it can feel like stepping into another language. Hallmarks, Georgian cuts, foil-backed stones — where to begin? The good news: you don’t need to be an expert. You just need curiosity, patience, and a few insider tips.
From understanding hallmarks and craftsmanship to choosing trusted sellers, here’s how to find a piece that speaks to you and will last a lifetime.
1. Start with the story, not the stone
Before you get technical, ask yourself what moves you. Is it the clean geometry of Art Deco design? The sentimentality of a Victorian locket, with initials engraved in looping script? Or the restrained sparkle of an Edwardian diamond ring, delicate as lace?
Each era carries its own personality — romantic, rebellious, refined — and finding the one that speaks to you is the first step towards a meaningful purchase.
2. Learn the eras that shaped jewellery
Understanding a little history helps you recognise authenticity and craftsmanship at a glance:
- Georgian (1714–1837): Handcrafted, intricate, often featuring closed-back settings that make stones glow from within.
- Victorian (1837–1901): Sentimental and symbolic — hearts, snakes, flowers — rendered in gold and garnet, turquoise, or pearls.
- Edwardian (1901–1915): Platinum filigree, old-cut diamonds, and airy designs made to complement lace and silk.
- Art Deco (1920s–1930s): Geometry, symmetry, coloured gemstones, and confidence — the jewellery of the modern woman.
- Mid-Century (1940s–1960s): Glamorous gold, sculptural lines, and the cocktail ring era — statement pieces born for the spotlight.
Knowing these broad strokes will help you see beyond surface sparkle to the character of a piece.
Browse our vintage and antique pieces!
3. Examine craftsmanship and condition
Antique jewellery carries subtle imperfections — a slightly uneven prong, a hand-cut gem, the gentle softening of metal over time. These details are evidence of the maker’s hand, not flaws.
When shopping online, look for clear, close photographs from multiple angles. Read descriptions carefully — mentions of “original settings,” “old mine-cut diamonds,” or “hand-engraved detail” are all good signs.
Minor wear is expected; missing stones or obvious repairs should be disclosed. At Gatsby, every piece is inspected for integrity and described transparently, so you know exactly what you’re buying.
4. Understand hallmarks — the jewellery’s passport
A hallmark tells you where and when a piece was made, what it’s made from, and sometimes, who made it. On a ring shank or clasp you might find:
- Metal purity — 9ct, 15ct, or 18ct gold, or “PT” for platinum.
- Assay office — a tiny mark for London, Birmingham, or Sheffield.
- Date letter — the year of hallmarking, like a hidden timestamp.
- Maker’s mark — the jeweller’s initials or symbol.
If it feels overwhelming, don’t worry — we can decode this for you. Still, learning to read a hallmark can turn every discovery into a small act of detective work.
5. Choose sellers who care as much as you do
A trustworthy seller is one who loves what they sell. Look for clear photography, detailed descriptions, and an open returns policy. Reputable dealers are proud of their sourcing and happy to answer questions.
At Gatsby, we hand-select every piece for its beauty, craftsmanship, and provenance. If we wouldn’t wear it ourselves, it doesn’t make the collection.
6. Remember: the right piece will find you
Unlike modern jewellery, vintage pieces don’t repeat. If you miss one, it’s gone — but that’s part of the magic. Wait for the piece that makes your pulse quicken; it’s often the one meant for you.
Buying antique jewellery isn’t about chasing trends. It’s about recognising beauty that has already stood the test of time — and choosing to carry that story forward.
→ Explore this week's most popular items and start your own chapter in the life of a jewel.
